Minelli, Alessandro (2021) On the Nature of Organs and Organ Systems – A Chapter in the History and Philosophy of Biology. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 9. ISSN 2296-701X
pubmed-zip/versions/1/package-entries/fevo-09-745564/fevo-09-745564.pdf - Published Version
Download (279kB)
Abstract
Contrasting definitions of organs based either on function or on strictly morphological criteria are the legacy of a tradition starting with Aristotle. This floating characterization of organs in terms of both form and function extends also to organ systems. The first section of this review outlines the notions of organ and body part as defined, explicitly or implicitly, in representative works of nineteenth century’s comparative morphology. The lack of a clear distinction between the two notions led to problems in Owen’s approach to the comparative method (definition of homolog vs. nature of the vertebrate archetype) and to a paradoxical formulation, by Anton Dohrn, of the principle of functional change. Starting from the second half of the twentieth century, with the extensive use of morphological data in phylogenetic analyses, both terms – organ and body part – have been often set aside, to leave room for a comparison between variously characterized attributes (character states) of the taxa to be compared. Throughout the last two centuries, there have been also efforts to characterize organs or body parts in terms of the underlying developmental dynamics, both in the context of classical descriptive embryology and according to models suggested by developmental genetics. Functionally defined organ are occasionally co-extensive with morphologically defined body parts, nevertheless a clear distinction between the former and the latter is a necessary prerequisite to a study of their evolution: this issue is discussed here on the example of the evolution of hermaphroditism and gonad structure and function.
Item Type: | Article |
---|---|
Subjects: | Open Archive Press > Multidisciplinary |
Depositing User: | Unnamed user with email support@openarchivepress.com |
Date Deposited: | 29 Jun 2023 04:16 |
Last Modified: | 04 Jun 2024 11:06 |
URI: | http://library.2pressrelease.co.in/id/eprint/1662 |